Hard critic on Shmuel, A., Leopold, D.A., 2008. Neuronal correlates of spontaneous fluctuations in fMRI signals in monkey visual cortex: implications for functional connectivity at rest. Hum. Brain Mapp. 29, 751–761

1. Intracellular recordings were made from bipolar and amacrine cells in the isolated goldfish retina. Cells were identified mainly from their response patterns to a spot and an annulus in reference to the knowledge obtained from the previous work of intracellular Procion Yellow injection. Using white light and monochromatic lights receptive field organization of recorded cells were analysed.2. All bipolar cells had a centre-surround organization in their receptive fields. The field centre was estimated to be 100-200 mum in diameter, and the surround 1-1.5 mm.3. Bipolar cells were classified into two types according to the response properties to monochromatic lights. Opponent colour cells received inputs from red and green cones, responding with red on-centre, red and green off-surround or vice versa. Cells without colour coding received input from red cones both in the field centre and the surround. In these cells the centre and the surround were well balanced.4. Amacrine cells were also classified into two types, a sustained type and a transient type. The sustained type amacrine cells responded with a steady potential change and were colour coded. They were hyperpolarized by red and depolarized by green light. The transient type amacrine cells responded with transient depolarization at on and off of light flashes. They received input chiefly from red cones and were not colour coded. Both types of amacrine cells showed a large spatial summation in an area over 2.5 mm; centre-surround antagonism was not seen.5. Comparing the size of the receptive field with anatomy, especially with the size of dendritic spread, the field centre of bipolar cells agreed in size with their dendritic spread. Bipolar cell surround clearly exceeded its dendritic field. Since the response properties of the bipolar cell surround was mimicked most closely by the receptive field of external horizontal cells, the input to the bipolar cell surround is thought to be mediated by external horizontal cells.6. By comparing receptive field properties of various retinal cells it is suggested that both the opponent colour bipolar cells and the colour coded amacrine cells converge on to the double opponent ganglion cells.

Amacrine cells of the goldfish retina were characterized electrophysiologically and subsequently labelled by intracellular injection of horseradish peroxidase. An attempt was made to broaden the electrophysiological classification of the cells. Light-evoked sustained amacrine cell responses were divided into two subtypes depending on colour opponency. Colour-coded responses (red/depolarizing and green/hyperpolarizing) were found to arise in amacrine cells possessing highly polarized dendritic fields; the dendrites were monostratified in the proximal half (sublamina b) of the inner plexiform layer. Non-colour-opponent sustained responses also arose in monostratified units, but the level of dendritic ramification was in sublamina a or b (hyperpolarizing or depolarizing units, respectively). Transient (ON-OFF) responses were associated mainly with bi- or multi-stratified or diffuse amacrine cells. Some variability was observed in the sizes of the dendritic fields in different sublaminae. There was a tendency for units with brisk components of responses to be narrowly stratified in the inner plexiform layer. Some units possessed "distant" dendrites. Several aspects of structure-function correlation in amacrine cells are discussed.